Email security for accountants: what ICAEW and ACCA say
Accountancy practices handle payroll, tax refunds, supplier payments and confidential client records. Much of that work runs on email, which makes a practice's email domain valuable to criminals. This guide sums up what the two main professional bodies say, points out what their guidance leaves out, and explains the settings that stop someone sending email as your practice.
The threat, in the profession's own terms
ACCA's November 2025 In Practice article on cyber resilience was published with its cyber partner PureCyber, which offers ACCA members a discount. It groups the most serious threats facing UK accountancy firms into six categories, and business email compromise and payment fraud is one of them. It describes three common tactics [3]:
- spoofing a partner or director to request an urgent supplier or tax payment
- posing as a client with "updated" bank details
- taking over a genuine firm mailbox to intercept or alter invoices
The article adds that many firms have no formal process for verifying payments, and that phishing is the most common way into accountancy firms. It also mentions fake HMRC refund emails and fake log-in pages for cloud accounting tools [3].
An April 2026 ICAEW Insights article makes the same point from another angle. Once criminals get into a mailbox, they can email a practice's clients from inside the firm. They can search for words like "payroll" or "BACS" and quietly start replying as you. An IT provider quoted in the article describes a scam in which criminals use a hijacked email address to file a false tax return through the HMRC portal and change the bank details, so the refund goes to them [2]. It adds that with ISQM on the agenda, cyber security is part of how a firm shows it is identifying and managing risk [2].
Accountants are not alone in this. In the government's Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/26, phishing was by far the most common attack, reported by 38% of UK businesses. The next most common was people impersonating an organisation or its staff in emails or online, reported by 12% [5].
What ICAEW recommends
ICAEW's Tech Essentials guide sets out ten steps. They cover allocating responsibility, firewalls, patching, access control, malware protection, remote working, removable and cloud storage, incident planning, training, and record-keeping and testing [1]. On email, it recommends scanning messages so that likely phishing is flagged and quarantined, rather than relying on staff spotting it. It also recommends regular phishing simulations [1]. The guide presents the ten steps as preparation for Cyber Essentials, and notes that the scheme was launched at Chartered Accountants' Hall in 2014 [1].
What ACCA recommends
The ACCA article's recommendations are layered defences, phishing-resistant MFA for partners and finance staff, vetting of suppliers, offline backups, ongoing awareness training and a breach response plan led by the board [3].
What both leave out
None of the three pages we read names SPF, DKIM or DMARC (checked 10 Nov 2026). Both focus on protecting the practice's own inbox: filtering, MFA, training and monitoring. That matters. But it doesn't stop a criminal sending an email that appears to come from your domain to one of your clients. The client's mail server makes that decision, and to tell a fake from the real thing it relies on the records you publish in DNS.
The NCSC explains those records [4]:
- SPF lists the servers that are allowed to send email for your domain.
- DKIM adds a cryptographic signature that proves an email came from you and wasn't changed.
- DMARC tells receiving servers what to do when an email claims to be from you but fails both checks. Ideally it tells them to reject it. DMARC also sends you reports, so you can see who is sending as your domain.
With DMARC set to p=reject, a fake invoice that uses your exact domain should be refused before your client ever sees it. With p=none, or no DMARC record at all, it is delivered like any other message.
Limits worth knowing
- DMARC protects your exact domain. A look-alike, such as
smith-accountants.coinstead ofsmithaccountants.co.uk, needs other defences. Train clients to check the sender's address. - If a real mailbox is taken over, the criminal's email passes every check, because it genuinely comes from you. MFA and monitoring of mailbox rules stay essential, as both bodies say [2][3].
- Tools that send email as you, such as practice management software, payroll portals and newsletter tools, must be set up in SPF and DKIM before you move DMARC to reject. Otherwise your own mail may be refused.
A checklist for practices
- Check that your main domain publishes SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
- List every service that sends email as your practice, and make sure each one passes SPF or DKIM.
- Move DMARC from
p=nonetop=quarantine, then top=reject, reading the reports at each step. - Protect domains you don't send email from with "no mail" records.
- Use MFA on every mailbox, phishing-resistant where you can, and review forwarding rules.
- Tell clients that your bank details will not change by email, and give them a known phone number to check.
- If money is lost, call your bank straight away. Then report it to Report Fraud in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, or to Police Scotland on 101 [6].
Check your domain free
You can check your practice's domain for free at faultypacket.co.uk. It shows in plain English whether SPF, DKIM and DMARC are in place and what your DMARC policy would do with a fake invoice. If something needs fixing, the £24 Fix Pack gives you the exact records to add, in a safe order, and re-checks each one live once you've added it.
DNS on Cloudflare? Fix it for me adds your SPF and DMARC records in one click (£49 plus VAT, Fix Pack included). To hear if anything changes later, monitoring checks your domain every day from £4 a month.
Guides for other sectors: Solicitors · Estate agents.
Sources
- ICAEW, "Cyber security: How to keep your organisation safe and secure online" (Tech Essentials guide): https://www.icaew.com/technical/technology/cyber-security/cyber-security-guidance/cyber-security-how-to-keep-your-organisation-safe-and-secure-online
- ICAEW Insights, "Cyber: could a bad actor be lurking in your email accounts?" (7 Apr 2026): https://www.icaew.com/insights/viewpoints-on-the-news/2026/apr-2026/cyber-could-a-bad-actor-be-lurking-in-your-email-accounts
- ACCA In Practice, "Building cyber resilience in accountancy" (Nov 2025): https://www.accaglobal.com/gb/en/technical-activities/uk-tech/in-practice-ezine-archive/In-Practice-archive-2025/November/Building-cyber-resilience-accountancy.html
- NCSC, "Email security and anti-spoofing": https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/collection/email-security-and-anti-spoofing
- DSIT and Home Office, "Cyber security breaches survey 2025/2026" (30 Apr 2026): https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/cyber-security-breaches-survey-20252026/cyber-security-breaches-survey-20252026
- NCSC, "Report a scam email": https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/collection/phishing-scams/report-scam-email